BO Play
B & oPlay H3, library intras
Aprox. 148€ - see price -
The H3 in-ear headphones are not a recent model of B & oPlay, the test of their version with active noise reduction (H3 ANC) has been online for a long time. But their popularity is such that one could not miss it: at the dawn of the launch of the H5, their elders, promising robustness, lightness and sound power, therefore come to parade on our test bench.
Our review
Ergonomics
The design of the H3 is strictly identical to that of the H3 ANC. The stainless steel lines are crisp and flowing, both curved and sharp. We find the 26 perforations all around the acronym of the brand used to improve the acoustics of the headphones, but also - according to the brand - to lighten the chassis.
That's good, light, they are, and robust too. These two points make H3 intras very pleasant to wear while giving them excellent resistance to bags, pockets and drops that any pair of headphones encounters during their lifetime. The connectors are also reinforced, at the level of the chassis and the mini-jack. We regret, however, that the latter is not bent (higher risk of breakage during listening with a walkman / smartphone slipped in his pocket).
The remote control, only iOS compatible, is complete and allows navigation between songs (pressing the central button to pause / play, two to go to the next song and three, at the start of the previous track / song), activation of voice recognition (a long press on the central button), volume control and call management. A microphone is also part of it, which offers an excellent reproduction of our voice: once is not custom, the correspondents prefer even when we use the hands-free kit of the H3 rather than the microphone of the phone itself - and the user himself hears his interlocutor better.
It is on the accessories side that the deal changes compared to their ANC version: the H3-tout-court are supplied with three pairs of tips of different sizes in silicone. They enter with disconcerting ease into our ear canal, and hold there almost as well, despite some regular repositioning necessary. Three silicone tips therefore ... but no memory foam in sight. A detail which, as we will see later, has an unfortunate consequence on the quality of the sound reproduction.
Audio
Since the acoustic design of the H3 and H3 ANCs is strictly the same, one would expect the measurements to be identical. And yet it is not.
We often tell you to really take the time to choose your tips properly, sometimes even even wearing different sizes on the left and on the right (it's like the feet, we don't necessarily wear the same size on both sides!), And it is not for nothing. Indeed, the H3, if listened to in a very calm environment and without moving, deliver an appreciable sound performance.
In our sound lab, the measurements are made exactly under these conditions. The sound rendering is in line with the design of the H3: clean, clean and generally balanced. Let's start with the bass, quite dynamic and precise. We cannot say that they are at the center of the stage, nevertheless they do not miss the call - our traditional intro sweep of Unfinished Sympathy is very noticeable, but does not either boxes. Here below is the measurement of square signals at 50 Hz which betray a nicely reactive and rather healthy behavior of the membranes of H3.
The same goes for the rest of the spectrum: the sound is detailed and pleasantly precise. The voices in particular enjoy an excellent definition and presence. We even reach at times this sensation of perceiving the different layers of the mix, a sensation that only the greats of the name can deliver. However, it lacks some support on the side of the low mids which would offer a better feeling of immersion. And precisely, let's talk about this immersion.
In fact, as soon as you start fidgeting with spunk - that is, simply moving around or, worse still, being in a noisy environment - everything gets spoiled. Indeed, the silicone tips are suitable for providing good comfort, but not for properly obstructing the ear canals. The first obvious consequence is an extremely weak, if not almost zero, isolation from the outside world. Note that this can be practical for many uses, and much less dangerous in urban areas. The second is a blatant loss of seat in the lower half of the spectrum: ciao the low mids and the bass!
These first two points therefore generate a serious lack of immersion. The third consequence, more insidious, is that we then tend, after having repeatedly repositioned the intras in our ears, to put stronger. A phenomenon then appears from which the H3s do not suffer at medium volume: sibilance. The peak of distortion that we see above is much less discreet, and the treble can become aggressive. Here is how, with a simple choice of ear tips, you can significantly change the sound performance of a pair of in-ear headphones.
Conclusion
The H3s honor their promise of robustness, lightness and elegance. Comfort and aesthetics are present, but an unfortunate choice of accessories tarnishes the sound table: the absence of memory foam ear tips considerably affects the quality of sound reproduction in noisy environments.
Reviews
CABLE NOISE IS ONLY USER ERROR. These earbuds are AWESOME.
I read through a lot of the reviews on these headphones before purchasing, and many of the complaints seemed to center around cable noise. I almost didn't buy because of these reviews, but I decided to take the risk and go for it anyway. I'm glad I didn't listen to the bad reviewers as they're simply flat out wrong.
I can confirm that the complaints about cable noise are simple pure user error.
They either haven't charged the battery, or haven't turned the unit on.
Look, here's how to use the headphones so you don't hear the cable:
Step one, turn on the headphones with the little slider switch on the battery pack by moving it up one position only into the middle of the slider like I have shown in my image. (obviously it won't work if you don't charge the battery via the USB charging cable, which might also be a source of the user error.)
1. If you haven't turned on the noise canceling yet, no LED appears, you can hear the cable noise like you can with any other earbuds. That's just simple physics y'all. (see image left side)
2. When you turn them on, a white LED appears, the noise canceling starts, and the cable noise totally disappears. Like as in DISAPPEARS COMPLETELY. Even when you scratch them all over your tshirt. 100% Gone. (see image middle)
3. If you need to put them on MUTE for a moment, just toggle up one more level, the audio playback gets muted, the noise canceling turns off, and you can hear the cable noise, along with whatever you're supposed to be listening to in your outside environment, like airport gate announcements or your kids screaming at you that your wife is at the store and that they need to be fed lunch while you're blissfully unaware, while working in your home office like just happened to me 5 minutes ago. (see image right side)
But aside from that * HOLY CRAP THESE THINGS SOUND UNBELIEVABLE! *
Surprisingly, the 10.8mm driver actually has better audio than my BOSE Quiet Comfort Series II over the ear bluetooth headphones with 50mm drivers.
MORE >> because they're wired headphones and not bluetooth, you won't be nuking the sides of your brain with bluetooth microwave radiation like you do with wireless headphones.
My BOSE headphones were giving me a headache which is why I replaced them with these wired earbuds.
Not to mention these little things are a heck of a lot easier for travel and long red-eye overnight flights.
To get insane sound quality from your computer / laptop / iOS device, also purchase and install the $ 23 BOOM 3D Audio app from the MAC App store to give you custom tailored surround sound and equalizer control. The earbuds are so good with that app that installed running virtual 3D surround you simply won't believe it.
Can't speak to durability of the cables over time as I just received them, but my guess is that they'll be fine as long as my kids and puppy don't get hold of them. The cable diameter is easily twice as thick as the stock headphones you get with an iPhone. They have adequate strain relief ends as well.
To wrap up, don't listen to the bashers as they're simply just flat out wrong.
These headphones are simply amazing. Period.
Sound is great!... but not for Android
I bought these and I also own the Bose QC20 noise cancelling earphones. I'm not sure which I like better at this point because both are very nice! These B&O do a great job at noise cancelling and they sound VERY good. You will be surprised to hear new sounds in the songs you thought you knew very well.
Today I was waiting to get my car washed on a very busy street and when I popped these in the vast majority of the annoying sound disappeared. However, I went to turn up the music using the inline remote and thats when I realized that the remote doesn't work with my Samsung phone. I was just looking at the Amazon page and didn't see anything that said this was a iphone only set of earphones. For this reason I have to return them.
Exceptional Noise Cancellation without white noise tricks
I have purchased several active noise canceling ear phones over the years. This includes JVC, TaoTronics, Linner, and Phiaton. This B & O is exceptional. On Long flights it completely suppress the exhausting drone of the airplane engines. No White Noise trickery is associated with this. It was by far superior to any of the other brands that I purchased over the years. My primary emphasis and interest is on the noise canceling and in this arena this earphones Is fantastic. I fly frequently with my family of eight. I was fortunate enough to test all of the aforementioned earphones on a recent flight as I was carrying them with me (a lot of kids
Excellent product
I bought these to replace a pair of Bose QC20 that I liked very much but had mis-treated. The B&O is fully equivalent in terms of excellent sound quality and noise cancellation. Two things I prefer in the B&O, the sound quality with and without noise cancellation is the same with the B&O (much inferior without cancellation on the Bose) and there is no pickup of noise when listening on my MacBook Air with the power supply plugged in with the B&O. The cabling on the B&O is very sturdy and the earbuds have an elegant look. Proper positioning in the ear and use of the right size rubber ear cups are required for good sound reproduction and noise cancellation, but this is not unique to the B&O.
If you like B&O sound
If you like B&O sound, you'll like these. Good bass without being over the top Beats sound, very good highs, but not quite as sharp as Etymotic's. But more bass than Etymotic's. A couple things I'd change, I wish these had foam tips included, I prefer those to the flexible mushroom type buds. Also, the mini plug would be damaged less if it were at a 90 degree angle as opposed to the straight plug provided.
NOTE the headphones I received were purchased new, but were a return as the headphones were rolled up in the box and not packaged from the factory. Amazon discounted the headphones for me as a convenience and I kept them, but be aware from this distributor at least, what's "new" may not be "new".
The Best Earbuds I have ever used
I have been looking at Bang & Olufson sound equipment since I first read about them in the 70's. Back then They were out of my price range, but in the hi-end rooms they sounded very good. A few days ago I was looking to BUY something on Black Friday .. I came across the H-3 actually on sale. I am beyond pleased.I bought them. For Tech. Heads they just came in first in a Consumer study on earphones under $ 300 .. Speakers and Head Phones have always been the heart of a good sound system..No matter how fancy The Gear your system will never sound better than your Speakers. I use the 65/45 plan when setting up systems 65% of cost Speakers 45% The rest. In Closing if you are looking for some good ear buds you found them .. Comfort I've had mine on 13 hours now, Range I have been running my music library through them, excellent separation, and a clean sound No Clutter or as Steely Dan put it No Static At All.